The Knave and the Moon by Rachel Gillig

The second in The Stonewater Kingdom duology by Rachel Gillig, The Knave and the Moon was released in September of 2026. It continues the story of Sybil, though she has to continue on without her friends and surrounded by those that she cannot trust. If you need to catch up on what happened in the first book in The Stonewater Kingdom, check out our recap page here. The following review will contain spoilers for The Knight and the Moth, so read with care. The Knave and the Moon deals with animal cruelty, body horror, bullying, death, suicidal thoughts, violence, grief, murder, injury, and classism.
Sybil's life has changed drastically, for the second time this year. After her fellow Diviners went missing, she went on a quest to find them which turned into a quest to rid the world of the Omens, bring down Aisling Cathedral, and avenge their deaths. She found love and friendship on that quest but that has been ripped away from her. Maude, Rory, and Bartholomew are all likely dead, and Benji has decided that he will marry Sybil and stand her up as a figurehead for what is left of Traum's religion - to help him solidify control of the very superstitious kingdom. He stages a series of tournaments to show the strength of him and his knights to the people, to show off his bride and remind him of who has inherited the gifts of the Omens. But nothing goes the way that Benji wants it to as a nameless knave rises to the top of the tournament lists, gaining the admiration of the people around him and Sybil realizes this knave may be just what she needs to complete her new quest: kill Benji and destroy what's left of Traum's faith in the Omens.
I must admit that I'm a bit disappointed with this book. I did enjoy it, but not nearly as much as I would have liked. It followed the progression of the first book in that Sybil has to go on a trek through all of Traum's hamlets. In the first book, she was destroying Omens while in this book she was taking part in the tournaments. I didn't love Sybil's progression here, she becomes quite pessimistic and angry. Not that I think she didn't have reason, it just seemed too drastic a change especially as the book progresses. I didn't love that there really wasn't a ton of development with the sprites. It drug on at times. It felt like so much happened in the first book that this one stayed a little bit stagnant. Plus, there wasn't enough Bartholomew. I didn't hate the ending though, I thought it was a nice little wrap up, but I wasn't entirely happy with it either.
I'm giving The Knight and the Moth by Rachel Gillig 4 stars out of 5. Spice is .5, nothing really to see. I still enjoyed it but it was probably the book I liked the least of hers.
For more from Rachel Gillig, check out https://rachelgillig.com/
Pairs well with dried apples and dipping your toe into the cold lake water.
My favorite quotes:
"What kind of kingdom had I woken to, where the privilege to exist was not guaranteed, but granted, perhaps by those most unfit to bestow it?"
"'Obscene,' said the gargoyle. 'Never trust anything written in rhyme.'"
"'I love a man of few words. Leaves the rest for me.'"
"'I will shoulder any weight you give me.'"

Comments